Posts

Showing posts from September, 2010

Interview with Justice Stephen Breyer on NBC

Image
 Justice Stephen Breyer  Tonight on the NBC Nightly News, Brian Williams presented an interesting interview with Justice Stephen Breyer on a number of different topics.  You can view the three different videos by clicking here .

Violation of Sixth Amendment Wrong, but Harmlessly So

Image
Have you ever had the situation arise where the prosecution cannot produce the toxicologist who performed the analysis of the drugs in your trial, and, instead, will produce another member of the lab to testify that they have reviewed the work of the analyst and they conclude that the controlled substance is what the report says it is? Turns out such a scenario violates the defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to confrontation of witnesses. In the case of People v Dendel , decided on August 24, 2010, Court of Appeals’ Judges Borrello and Saad, with Judge Wilder concurring, held that when the CEO of an independent laboratory (AIT Laboratories) testifies to facts in a report from another analyst at his lab, such testimony violates the confrontation clause and the United States Supreme Court’s ruling in Melendez-Diaz v Massachusetts , decided last year. Katherine Dendel was convicted following a bench trial before the Honorable Chad Schmucker in the Jackson County Circuit Court. The pros...